
2027 Gold Circle Awards
Standard Criteria and Guidance For All Categories
Across all categories, strong applications should include purposeful objectives, intentional strategies, well-executed tactics, and measurable results that demonstrate meaningful progress toward stated goals. Applications should be written clearly so judges can easily understand all aspects of the project.
Timing: The project or campaign must have been active and/or completed during the preceding calendar year. For example, applications for Gold Circle Awards in 2027 should cover projects active and completed in 2026. A project that began in 2025 and concluded in 2026 is acceptable for a 2027 award (for example, a Convention/Meetings Marketing campaign for an event in February 2026), but a project that concluded before year-end 2025 would no longer be eligible. Likewise, a project completed in early 2027 (or not yet complete) would not be eligible for a 2027 award and should instead be submitted in 2028.
Conscious Inclusion: ASAE is committed to fostering conscious inclusion in associations. Gold Circle Award applicants are encouraged to share how their projects apply a conscious inclusion lens to their design or implementation.
Use of Artificial Intelligence in Award Applications: Gold Circle Award applications should be developed, reviewed, and submitted by association professionals (i.e., humans). Use of AI to assist in developing award applications is permitted, but the association professional submitting the application is ultimately responsible for its content, quality, and accuracy. Gold Circle Award judges seek quality and clarity in the applications they evaluate; thus, applications that are clearly and predominantly AI-generated are likely to be judged poorly. For more general guidance, see ASAE’s Artificial Intelligence Policy.
Common Criteria for Applications: See the Gold Circle Awards Judging Rubric for full details on how applications are evaluated. Below, find several core criteria sought in all applications.
Project Goals/Objectives
- Goals and objectives are clearly defined, strategically sound, and measurable.
- Objectives align with the applications’ purpose, audience, and intended outcomes.
Strategies/Tactics
- Strategies are clear, intentional, and aligned with stated goals.
- Tactics support the strategy and are executed effectively across relevant channels.
- Content, tone, design, and accessibility are of high quality and appropriate to the intended audience and purpose.
- Methods deployed show creativity or innovation in execution.
Success Metrics/Results Achieved
- Results demonstrate achievement of stated success metrics.
- Metrics are measurable, relevant, and tied directly to goals.
- Evidence may include a wide range of metrics such as engagement, reach, revenue, attendance, retention, recruitment, analytics, downloads, participation, and/or call-to-action outcomes. (See individual category descriptions for more.)
- Success is evaluated by the alignment of goals, strategy, tactics, and results.
Categories
- Advocacy
- Convention/
Meetings Marketing - E-Newsletters
- Membership Recruitment
- Membership Retention
- Member/
Volunteer Engagement - Mobile Apps
- New Product/
Service Marketing - Podcasts
- Publications
- Public Relations/
Media Outreach - Rebranding
- Sponsorship/
Exhibits/ Advertising Promotion - Video
- Website
Category Descriptions & Criteria
Advocacy
Recognizes an outstanding legislative, regulatory, PAC, or grassroots advocacy campaign, with efforts primarily targeted to lawmakers and aimed at influencing change in public policy. (For public awareness-focused campaigns, see Public Relations/Media Outreach).
Campaign elements may include targeted communications to lawmakers and relevant influencers, including advocacy day, content marketing, media advisories, op-eds, press releases, pitch letters/emails, bytes and b-roll packages, satellite media tours, fact sheets, backgrounders, position statements, social media, and other supporting materials.
Success metrics include (but are not limited to): outcomes or evidence of legislative action or support, increased PAC donations, volume of grassroots engagement, quantity and reach of resulting media coverage, etc.
Convention/Meetings Marketing
Recognizes an outstanding campaign to promote an association convention, meeting, or tradeshow. The event should have taken place in the preceding calendar year (e.g., in 2026 for a 2027 award). Recognizing that major association events have long marketing cycles, a project that began in 2025 and concluded in 2026 is acceptable for a 2027 award.
Campaign elements may include event web pages or microsites, print and digital promotional pieces, social media, video, apps, and other supporting materials.
Success metrics include (but are not limited to): attendance, revenue, conference sponsorship, attendee engagement, registration funnel rate, session views (if offering hybrid or on-demand options), app or online community engagement (e.g., pre-event vs. during vs. post-event), etc.
E-Newsletters
Recognizes an outstanding electronic newsletter that provides valuable information to members, prospective members, and/or staff. The e-newsletter must include original content from the organization.
Success metrics include (but are not limited to): open rates, click-throughs, subscriber growth, pageviews, session length, subject-line performance, subscriber or advertising revenue, social media reach, readership survey results, etc.
Membership Recruitment
Recognizes an outstanding membership recruitment campaign targeting individuals and/or organizations. Target audiences may include first-time prospects, former members (win back/re-instatement), or under-represented segments the association has identified.
Campaign elements may include web pages/microsites, print and digital promotion pieces, social media, video, apps, and other supporting materials.
Entries should report gross new members and net membership change for the same period, as numbers and percentages against goals, plus associated revenue (noting any introductory or discounted rates).
Additional success metrics include (but are not limited to): results for targeted segments, market penetration, cost per acquisition, member lifetime value, first-year retention of the recruited cohort, prospect-to-member conversion rate, channel-level performance, etc.
Membership Retention
Recognizes an outstanding membership retention program designed to retain individuals and/or organizations as members of the association.
Campaign elements may include web pages/microsites, print and digital pieces, social media, telemarketing, texting, video, apps, and other supporting materials.
Success metrics include (but are not limited to): retention rate percentage (based on goal), first-year retention rate, engagement metrics, revenue projection and revenue results compared to goals, etc.
Member/Volunteer Engagement
Recognizes an outstanding program that engages members and volunteers in the association.
Engagement activities may include committees and task forces, microvolunteering and other short-duration roles, virtual and hybrid volunteer opportunities, mentorship and peer-to-peer programs, communities of practice or affinity groups, online discussion forums and social media, training, special projects, fundraising, and other programs. Strong entries will define the target audience(s), including any under-engaged segments, and explain how participants were matched to opportunities.
Entries should report the increase in participating members, as numbers and percentages against goals, plus depth of participation (e.g., hours contributed or roles filled).
Success metrics include (but are not limited to): repeat participation or retention of volunteers, conversion from first-time to ongoing engagement, time-to-first engagement for new members, volunteer satisfaction measures, and/or downstream effects on member retention.
Mobile Apps
Recognizes an outstanding association mobile app effort targeted at the public, the association membership, or other stakeholder group(s). This can include a general association app, meeting/event app, advocacy app, fundraising app, and any other mobile app utilized by your organization.
Success metrics include (but are not limited to): analytics measured against stated goals, such as evidence of member and stakeholder engagement, app downloads, measured results for a call to action, engagement, active/repeat usage, usability improvements, accessibility, etc.
New Product/Service Marketing
Recognizes an outstanding campaign to promote a new product or service launch or the substantial repositioning or re-invention of an existing product/service (i.e., repackaging or bundling). (Rebranding of an existing product or service is not appropriate for this category; see Rebranding.) Note: This category focuses on the quality of the promotion of a new product or service, not necessarily the quality of the product or service itself.
Campaign elements may include web pages/microsites, print and digital promotion pieces, social media, video, apps, and other supporting materials for the new product or service launch.
Success metrics include (but are not limited to): revenue as a result of the product/service, ROI, proof of member engagement with the product/service, product’s effect on member recruitment/retention, etc.
Podcasts
Recognizes an outstanding association podcast targeted at the public, the association membership, or other stakeholder group(s). Podcasts must be distributed in audio format; video distribution is optional. (For video-only programs, see Video.)
Success metrics may include (but are not limited to): analytics measured against stated goals, such as evidence of member and stakeholder engagement, number of listeners, listening time, number of downloads, reviews, results for a call to action, follower growth, etc.
Publications
Recognizes an outstanding publication that provides valuable information to members, prospective members, or staff. Entries may include magazines, blogs, or other periodicals in print and/or digital format with the exception of email newsletters, which have a separate category; see E-Newsletters. Publications must be published at least two times per year. For print publications, applicants may submit physical copies to be reviewed or digital-only versions. Please refer to the Eligibility page for additional instructions on submitting print copies with your application.
Success metrics include (but are not limited to): circulation trends; readership tracking (e.g., number of existing subscribers/new subscribers); advertising revenue; web visits and time on page; delivery, open, and click-through rates; readership survey results; social media engagement or impressions; reader engagement; etc.
Public Relations/Media Outreach
Recognizes an outstanding overall public relations or media engagement campaign designed around the association or one of its initiatives, programs, products/services, or special events, with the purpose of garnering earned media coverage and/or building relationships with journalists and influencers. The campaign could also be designed to promote the association’s profession/industry or to respond to a crisis. (This category does not include campaigns for conferences or for government-relations advocacy efforts; see Convention/Meetings Marketing or Advocacy, respectively.)
Campaigns in this category must primarily focus on engaging external media professionals, outlets, and/or digital influencers. Owned (internal) media channels or those directed primarily at members may be a supporting component. For projects focused solely on members, see Member/Volunteer Engagement.
Campaign elements may include media advisories, press releases, content marketing, pitch letters/emails, bytes and b-roll packages, op-eds, satellite media tours, fact sheets, backgrounders, position statements, social media and engagement components, and other supporting materials.
Success metrics include (but are not limited to): engagement; volume, quality, and reach of resulting media coverage; share of voice; sentiment analysis; website traffic; media open or response rates; etc.
Rebranding
Recognizes an outstanding rebranding campaign of an association or an association’s major product, event, or service. Far from just a visual identity change, it should be the creation of a new name, symbol, design, mission, or a combination of these elements. Entries should be aimed at repositioning the brand to communicate a new mission/objective for the association.
Campaign elements may include web pages/microsites, print and digital promotion pieces, social media, video, apps, and other supporting materials. Entrants are encouraged to provide “before and after” samples to illustrate the change from old brand to new.
Success metrics include (but are not limited to): membership recruitment, retention or engagement; revenue; public awareness or industry visibility; product/service usage; event attendance, etc.
Sponsorship/Exhibits/Advertising Promotion
Recognizes an outstanding program designed to generate non-dues revenue through sponsorship programs, exhibits, and/or advertising. This can include campaigns focused on one of these areas or integrated campaigns covering more than one.
Campaign elements may include prospectus pieces, media kits, web pages/microsites, print and digital promotion pieces, creation of new assets or packages, social media, video, apps, and other supporting materials.
Success metrics include (but are not limited to): company engagement, new vs. returning buyers, sales, revenue, etc.
Video
Recognizes an outstanding original promotional or informative video or video series produced by an association for distribution via the web, social media, or television. Full-length video recordings of conference sessions, training programs, or webinars are not appropriate for this category.
Success metrics include (but are not limited to): viewership analytics (i.e., average view duration, completed views, percentage of viewers, percentage of new viewers, performance against benchmarks), actions/conversions (i.e., click-through rates, downloads, registrations, inquiries), meaningful engagement (i.e., shares, saves, comments, reposts, mentions, conversations generated—not simply likes), content longevity (i.e., continued views, engagement, traffic or conversions for defined period after “launch,” if applicable), reach beyond existing audience (i.e., earned media pickup, percentage of new viewers/audience, partner sharing, influencer amplification), and ROI (i.e., results relative to investment-cost per completed view, earned reach versus paid reach).
Website
Recognizes an outstanding association website targeted at the public, the association membership, or other stakeholders. This category includes association general websites, issue-specific sites, public education/campaign sites, event sites, policy-related sites, or any other websites created by the association.
Success metrics include (but are not limited to): website traffic and unique visitors during campaign cycle/year, engagement including time on site, pages per visit, and return visits, conversion rates for key actions for campaign (i.e., registrations, downloads, donations, etc.), measurable performance against prior year or organizational benchmarks, search impressions and clicks, search rankings for priority keywords, demonstrated reach and engagement among priority stakeholders/audience, etc.