ASAE Gold Circle Awards

Frequently Asked Questions

Eligibility

Why should I enter the Gold Circle Awards (GCA) competition?

The Gold Circle Awards represent the best of association marketing, membership, and communications. A Gold Circle Award demonstrates the excellence of your work to your peers, fellow staff members, and your membership.

Winners are announced at ASAE’s Marketing, Membership, Communications + Tech Conference (MMC+Tech), May 10-11, 2027. Along with recognition on ASAE’s website, conference sessions, and other relevant outlets, winners receive an engraved trophy.

Who is eligible to enter?

The Gold Circle Awards competition is open to all 501(c) nonprofit organizations, whether they belong to ASAE or not. For-profit business partners may also enter on behalf of a nonprofit, but the award goes to the nonprofit.

What is the eligibility period for the 2027 Gold Circle Awards program?

Projects must have been active and completed in 2026.

  • Eligible: A project that began in 2025 and concluded in 2026—for example, a Convention/Meetings Marketing campaign for a February 2026 event.
  • Ineligible: A project that concluded before the end of 2025 is not eligible, and a project completed in early 2027 should be entered next year.
  • Ongoing programs: Enter projects such as publications, e-newsletters, and other ongoing efforts based on work produced and results achieved through 2026.

How do I submit an entry?

Applicants in all categories must submit an electronic entry form through the entry portal (even if you are submitting print materials in the Publications category) and pay the entry fee.

Do entry materials need to arrive by January 29, 2027, or just be postmarked?

All entries must be submitted online by 11:59 p.m. ET on January 29, 2027.

If you are submitting a print publication or any materials that require hard-copy samples, those materials must be received (not postmarked) at ASAE headquarters by 5:00 p.m. ET on January 29, 2027 to be considered. Any required check payments must also be received by this deadline.

Why is the deadline so early when winners aren’t notified until April?

The judging process takes about two months:

  • February: ASAE staff and GCA Committee leadership team review judges and their assignments to prevent conflicts of interest.
  • Mid-February – mid-March: Judges review and score all entries.
  • Mid-March: Category winners are selected during final judging meetings.
  • Early April: After category winners are selected, the GCA Committee chooses a GCA Overall Excellence winner.
  • April: Winners are notified in advance of MMC+Tech.

This timing upholds the integrity of the program and its standards, allowing all entries to be thoughtfully considered.

What goes into the application?

The application has five written sections plus supporting materials, all scored on a 100-point rubric:

Section Word Limit Points
Project Overview 500 15
Goals and Objectives 500 15
Strategy and Tactics 500 15
Results and Metrics/Impact 500 25
Creativity and Innovation 300 15
Supporting Materials — 15

Results carry the most weight, so give judges specific outcomes, with a baseline, target, and actual result for each objective. The sample application template provides detailed guidance for each section.

May I use AI to help prepare my application?

Yes. AI can assist, but the application must be developed, reviewed, and submitted by association professionals. The association professional who submits the application is ultimately responsible for its content, quality, and accuracy. Judges evaluate applications for quality and clarity, so applications that appear to be clearly and predominantly AI-generated are likely to score poorly. Applicants should also review ASAE’s AI Policy for general guidance.

What is the difference between the Publications and E-Newsletter Categories?

  • Publications are magazines, blogs, or other periodicals in print or digital format, with the exception of email newsletters. If submitting a print publication, print samples must be received by ASAE headquarters by January 29, 2027, at 5:00 p.m. ET to be considered for this category.
  • E-Newsletters are digital periodicals that are deployed through email and may include a web-based copy of the content in an online archive.

How does conscious inclusion factor into my application?

Conscious inclusion is not scored. Judges note whether a project incorporates elements of ASAE’s commitment to conscious inclusion and may add comments. Since there’s no separate question, include any relevant strategies or results in the sections where they fit. For example:

  • Goals and Objectives: an audience or segment you aimed to reach or serve better
  • Strategy and Tactics: how you reduced barriers to participation or access
  • Results and Metrics/Impact: what changed for those audiences

Learn more about ASAE’s commitment to conscious inclusion.

How much time does ASAE estimate that preparing an entry will take?

Most applicants can expect to spend 3 to 10 hours to assemble an application. To save time and build a strong entry, prioritize specifics over storytelling. Focus on concise text or bullet points that cover the key judging criteria. There’s no need to restate your mission in your responses. Using the sample application template will help ensure a complete application that fits the word limit.

Fees & Submission Process

What is the cost to enter? Can my colleague sponsor our entry so that we can receive the member rate for the entry fee?

  • Non-members: $300
  • ASAE members (including entries sponsored by a member of your organization’s staff): $150

How do I pay the entry fee?

ASAE accepts credit card payments or checks. If you are paying by check, ensure it is received by January 29, 2027. Also, you MUST list the check number on your electronic application. If you are submitting an entry requiring hard copies, please include a copy of the check with the entry.

Proof of payment should be sent along with your entry submission by attaching a PDF copy of your confirmation.

Can I submit multiple entries?

Yes, each organization can submit up to two entries per category. Each entry requires a separate entry form, including the additional entry fee and any required samples.

An organization may not submit the same entry to multiple categories.

If I submit an entry for one category, but the judges decide that my entry should be in a different category, will it automatically be moved?

Your entry will be checked for accuracy and to make sure it is in the appropriate category. If time allows, ASAE will contact you to submit corrections to your entry. However, as stated in the Gold Circle Awards Eligibility Requirements, ASAE reserves the right to disqualify any entry that includes incomplete or incorrect information.

Judging and Recognition

How are entries judged?

An independent panel of judges evaluate submissions within each category, according to the criteria listed within the category descriptions on the Gold Circle Awards website. Entries are scored on a 15 or 25-point scale within each area of review. Please review the rubric for more details.

Who are the judges?

The judges are volunteers recruited from ASAE membership with experience in specific categories. Anyone with marketing, membership, and communications expertise can volunteer to serve as a judge. The Gold Circle Awards Committee reviews and approves all requests to serve as judge.

Can I participate as a judge if my association has entered the competition?

Yes, but not in any category in which your organization or your clients have entered.

Is judging eligible for CAE credit?

No.

How are winners notified?

Following the judging and selection process, ASAE will notify all applicants via email of the outcome of their entry, whether they have been selected as winners or not.

Will ASAE help me with promoting the news if my organization wins an award?

Yes. ASAE issues a press release recognizing all winners and will also provide you with your own press release template to spread the word among your media contacts and members.

Will you return my entry materials following the application period?

No. Entries become the property of ASAE and may be included in the Knowledge Center.

Will I receive feedback on my entry following the competition?

Possibly. If judges elect to share comments, their feedback will be provided to you after judging ends.

Can I appeal the results?

No. Decisions agreed to by the Gold Circle Awards judges are final. Entrants are not permitted to lobby for entry.

What is the Gold Circle Awards for Overall Excellence and how is it selected?

The Gold Circle Awards Committee selects a Gold Circle Award for Overall Excellence from all the category winners each year as “the best of the best.” The recipient of this award is announced during ASAE’s Marketing, Membership, Communications + Tech Conference (MMC+Tech).

Where can I see past winners?

Past Gold Circle Awards winners can be viewed here. This list is updated each year.

Additional questions?

Please email goldcircle@asaecenter.org.